Monday, May 9, 2011

Phil's Last Game

It is true, of course, that one disgusting game should not diminish the long and legendary career of Phil Jackson. It is true, of course, that one meltdown -- no matter how complete and degrading -- should not make anyone forget how great the Los Angeles Lakers have been the last three years, and really throughout the career of Kobe Bryant. It is true, of course, that random acts of frustrated violence perpetrated by Lamar Odom and Andrew Bynum should not take anything away from the brilliance of Bryant or the urbane nature of Pau Gasol or the wonderful class of Derek Fisher.

That said: Is anyone else wondering why the heck the sports world isn't a bit more outraged by the freak show that happened in Dallas on Sunday? The Lakers -- the two-time defending champion Los Angeles Lakers -- lost by 36 to get swept by Dallas. They exhibited no pride whatsoever. They quit.



There is nothing whatsoever to admire about quitters, but it is also not especially interesting. Quitting is pretty common thing in sports. The Lakers probably understood pretty early in this series that they were outmanned by the Mavericks, that Dirk Nowitzki and Jason Kidd -- two of the best players in NBA history to never win a championship -- were intensely focused and driven, that the Mavs were deeper and more athletic and, frankly, more determined to win. It takes a deep commitment to give anything close to the max in a doomed effort, and the Lakers as a team saw their doom and were unwilling to fight to the end. Hey, they've won their championships. Quit happens.

But what doesn't often happen, at least not so openly, is for a quitting team to go rogue before our very eyes. Usually, quitting is by its nature a passive act. That is to say that if you can't find the energy and enthusiasm to give an effort in a clinching game, you probably won't find the effort to take a series of cheap shots either. But the Lakers found that cheap-shot energy. Lamar Odom plainly sent a flying elbow at Dirk Nowitzki and got himself ejected. Then, barely a minute later, Andrew Bynum threw his own elbow -- even MORE flagrantly, if that's possible -- at a driving and defenseless J.J. Barea. Bynum got tossed out of the game too, though he managed to take off his shirt before exiting. So he had that going for him.

And, of course, Ron Artest got himself suspended for clotheslining Barea at the end of Game 2. The Lakers really covered themselves in glory.

We' will want to say again (because it's apparently the thing to say) that this shameful and abominable exit should not diminish from Phil Jackson's long and breathtaking career ... but it sure doesn't leave a happy echo. No champion in memory has gone out with such a lack of class. No great team in memory had so little respect for their coach that they sent him off in such a disgraceful fashion. And what made this meltdown even more remarkable was the casual way that Odom and Bynum admitted after the game that, yeah, they kind of lost their heads and kind of did something naughty. Really? That's it? Would you accept that if your nine-year-old told you that? How about your six-year-old?

"It's a little embarrassing," Odom told reporters afterward. "I'm a little embarrassed by it."

Here's a tip for Lamar for the next time something like this happens: Try not to use the word "little" twice when talking about how you cold-cocked someone because you were getting humiliated. At least Odom felt that slight embarrassment, Bynum said that the only embarrassment he felt was that Barea was schooling his team. "So I fouled the guy," he said, as if it made perfect sense.

Even Jackson himself sounded pretty blase about the whole thing: "It was unnecessary," he said of the cheap shots, "but I know they were frustrated." How about that defense from the great man? Hey, they were frustrated. Well, OK, whoa, I didn't take into consideration that they were frustrated. That certainly changes everything.

The NBA is a violent league. That is easy to miss on TV -- just like the size of the players and their amazing athleticism is easy to miss. The players pound each other. Hard fouls are close to battery. Playoff hard fouls are like assault and battery. And even in this setting, the Odom and Bynum fouls were hideous. The whole "role model" card gets played way too often, and sometimes I think the expectations we place on our athletes can be unfair. But "Do not just punch a player when he's driving the lane" -- I don't think it's unfair to ask players to stick to that one.

I don't know how leagues do their suspensions. I don't know what charts they use. But it sure seems to me me that there aren't too many worse things you can do in sports than purposely try to hurt your opponent because you are mad they're winning. That seems to me to break fundamental rules that go way beyond so many other sports-centric things we argue about like steroids and filming opponents sidelines and so on. You can't walk up to somebody and slug them because they beat you to the cab. You can't reach across the table and club the person who isn't offering what you deem a fair price on your house. Well, you CAN, but could find yourself in court. Sports isn't like real life. But there are real life limits in sports too.

The Lakers exit was pretty stunning just as a sports story. Coming into the series, the Lakers had their reputation as a team that rises to the moment, and the Mavs, to be blunt, had their reputation as a team that has not. But Dallas utterly outclassed Los Angeles. And the Lakers handled that about as poorly as it is possible to handle it. They disgraced themselves, their team, their league and their coach. They managed to go from champions to the very opposite of the word in four short games.

A friend says he hopes Bynum gets some kind of massive, attention-grabbing suspension but he probably won't. No he probably will get a two-gamer or something, and the world will move on. Heck, it seems like the world has already moved on. But Phil Jackson retires now, and if he stays retired then he cannot change that his final game represented the very worst of sports. Does it diminish the amazing career? No. But the amazing career also doesn't lift up the lousy final chapter.

33 comments:

  1. I am totally in agreement here. While I've never been fond of the Lakers, I respected that they were a good, well-coached team. They did not look like yesterday, and I thought Phil would be more upset about the team's play and behavior than he showed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. how'd you like to be the next coach taking over this mess?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think what makes this whole incident worse is that the Mavs had their hands tied when it came to defending themselves. This was like punching someone with their hands tied behind their back. The Mavs had their next playoff series coming up and no-one on their team could afford to get suspended for that series.
    The League needs to come down extremely hard on the Lakers or make an suspension exception for players that have effectively won a series but get assaulted while waiting out the final minutes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @cd1515: "This mess"? They were the #2 seed in the West and won the last two NBA Championships (and were in the Finals the previous year, too). And that same core of players (Kobe, Gasol, Odom, and Bynum) are all returning. I mean, I hate the Lakers, but as a Knicks fan (and I'm sure most other fans would agree), I sure do envy their problems, especially given that they'll probably add a player or two through the draft and free agency (barring a lock-out).

    TMore on-topic, what do people think is a good suspension for Bynum at the start of next year? 5 games? 10? More? Personally, I'd go with at least 10, because while the end result might not have been devastating (Barea seemed fine later one), the intent was sure there.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that it was incredibly bush league for the Lakers to act like that, but why don't many sportswriters and fans seem to care when Player C gets thrown at in a baseball game because Player A and Player B hit home runs? I've never understood that, either.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with everything Joe wrote, except I think the sports world really is outraged over what happened. Did anyone see Magic's comments after the game?

    ReplyDelete
  7. What I don't understand is why Phil didn't call a timeout after the Odom cheap shot and tell them that champions like the Lakers don't act this way. As far as that goes, why didn't Kobe put a stop to it?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Even the ESPN announcers on the Monday night game seemed to be outraged by it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Law student here. I agree with everything but the use of assault and battery. Tortious assault is a threat, leading one to believe that bodily harm will follow. So saying "JJ, I'm going to elbow you in the chest if you come in the lane again" is assault. Battery is when Bynum delivered the elbow. Barea could sue in civil court if he was injured.

    Criminal assault is the attempt to commit the battery. So if Bynum went up for the elbow and wiffed, he'd be charged with assault in criminal court, but not battery.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Besides Miami, consider the remaining NBA teams that remain in this year's playoffs. This is more like what NHL playoffs have become of late where the seeding hardly matters. I like it this way, especially if Atlanta (?) or Chicago can beat the Heat!

    ReplyDelete
  11. @dan-O

    Your explanation of tortious assault isn't entirely accurate. You don't have to announce that you are going to hit the person; they just have to see it coming. If you were looking at me and I picked up a chair and hit you with it, that would be both assault and battery because you would be in apprehension of immediate harmful conduct. If I hit you in the back of the head and you didn't see it coming, then that's only battery and not assault. What happened with Barea could go either way, depending on if he saw Bynum coming, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  12. dan-O, lawyer here. Your explanation of criminal assault isn't entirely accurate. In many jurisdictions, criminal assault includes the concept of common law battery.

    ReplyDelete
  13. How about suspensions for actions in playoff games are applied to the next set of playoff games for that player? So if Bynum gets 4 games, they're the next 4 playoff games he's in.
    I also have always wanted a rule that if you injure someone on a cheap shot/rule violation, you're out as long as they are. If you end their career, you just ended your own.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I am sure this guy was proud of what he saw.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The Lakers quit in the deciding game against the Celtics in '08, too. The cheap shots were a new twist, though.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The game was a disgrace, and Phil Jackson's legacy should be tainted.

    But I think the overriding message will be that Phil Jackson's brilliant zen coaching abilities allowed him to take self-centered guys like Kobe and raving lunatics like Artest and mold them into a championship team. And this last game only served to underscore how dysfunctional the characters on the team really were. It was almost like Phil wanted his team to go nuts, as if to say, "Do you see what I've had to deal with?"

    Of course, Phil didn't have control over the team in that game. I don't know what the excuse will be for that. Maybe it will be that Phil was too old and tired to impose his will anymore. Or maybe Phil had handed the leadership reins over to Kobe so Kobe could prove his leadership. Either way, it's probably not going to be Phil Jackson's fault this happened.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The 2 time defending champion Pistons were pretty classless in the way they handled being swept out of the playoffs by the Bulls in 1991. I don’t remember them taking any cheap shots the way Bynum did, but then again their whole persona for the championship years was “Bad Boys” – with physical, and dirty, play built right in.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wow, I just watched video of the foul and that was pretty disgusting. Andrew Bynum is an absolute disgrace. He should get somewhere around a 15-20 game suspension (without pay) IMO. That cheap shot merits him missing at least a huge chunk of next season.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Considering the gap between this game and when the suspension will take effect, it will have to be a pretty long suspension if the league's going to make a point. Two games in October for something that happened in May? eh... Should at least be 10, if not more.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I agree with the poster above who mentioned beanballs in baseball. Nobody is ever outraged about that, nor does Joe write any articles condemning it.

    And I would argue that in baseball its actually worse given that its usually premeditated and often ok'd by managers. The two fouls by Odom/Bynum were much more reactionary than anything. This is in no way a justification for their actions, just found it interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Dave V, have you ever watched an NBA game before? You get a one game suspension for hitting somebody in the head. I expect maybe a one game suspension, and possibly no suspension.

    And here's the other reason why. Bynum played the whole series receiving cheap shot fouls below the waist. They're just as illegal, and he fell several times because of it. The refs just didn't call it, maybe because when you have so many acres of players in the paint, you just can't see anything. Phil Jackson pointed it out, and got slapped with a $35,000 fine for complaining. It was even a topic on NPR last night. Some commentators feel that this was David Stern's last shot at a star coach who never held back from criticizing the league. It makes Stern look like a cheap shot artist himself.

    And did you look at the end of game one, the game the Lakers would have won with balanced refereeing? Pau Gasol pushes Nowitzki, a play that usually does not get called in the last minute, but Nowitzki's free throws put the Mavs up. Then Bryant got knocked down, a virtually identical play, and it did not get called.

    So the refs were a big factor in this series ending when it did, and I think the reason the Lakers quit. When your contacts all get called, and theirs don't, it's hard to stay motivated. or stay clean.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Mark Daniel, yeah, this was a team that wasn't much of a team. But Jackson lost game one. Or maybe Kobe did (the only player who could have called time out and not get reamed by Jackson). You just don't let a team get that hot without calling a time out. When the Lakers were building a 16 point lead, there were two time outs called (one in each half) to slow them down. I know Jackson challenges his players to get better on the court. But Fisher is old, Bynum and Artest are not the smartest or most disciplined guys, and I think Gasol was playing in pain the whole series.

    And maybe that's a factor as well. Maybe Jackson decided that if this team didn't have the maturity to straighten itself out, Jackson didn't want to deal with them for one or two more series. That had to start in the first round. If the Lakers were really a championship team, they had to sweep the first series to rest their old guys.

    ReplyDelete
  23. In most cases, the pitcher does not intentionally hit the next player (after a home run) in the head. He aims low to drive him off the plate. There have been head hunters, but they are rare, and rules now allow umpires to give a warning and then to toss any pitcher he thinks is trying to hit batters.

    I am not in favor of intentionally hitting batters, but the distinction between pitching inside and doing that is often fuzzy. The brushback pitcher, high and inside, is dangerous and there are debates about its legitimacy, but the intention is not to hit the batter.

    ReplyDelete
  24. And yet, Dwyane Wade gets a pass for dislocating an elbow and altering a series. The Lakers were dumb, but no one was hurt. And Kobe and Fisher went into the Mavs locker room to apologize after the game.

    ReplyDelete
  25. @Dinky - yes, I have watched an NBA game before. You say you expect a one game suspension and possibly no suspension...but what do you think Bynum actually deserves? If you can honestly say you think he deserves a suspension of only one game or maybe even no games, well all I can say is WOW. And your rationalization of why the dirty play was okay? Again WOW.

    ReplyDelete
  26. how many games was magic suspended for after this play?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=rbJjAejlef4

    ReplyDelete
  27. Why isn't the sports world more outraged? Maybe because a big segment of the sports world doesn't care much about the NBA, largely because Odom and Bynum pretty much represent what the NBA has become. Hey, it was a Sunday in May, there's baseball, there's a world outdoors, who wants to sit inside watching one in an endless stream of mostly dull basketball games?

    And Jackson's greatness? Hard to say. Yes, a big part of coaching is massaging egos, and Jackson is good at that. And this year's Lakers are proof that even a good coach can't win with dysfunctional players. But Jackson's career consists (so far) of coaching two teams, each of which had the best player in the game during his tenure. Playoff game plan: get ball to great player, watch great player take over game. It would be interesting to see him coach a good team without the best player in the game, see if his genius elevates that team to the championship.

    ReplyDelete
  28. @Dinky: Um, have *you* ever watched an NBA game before? Guys receive suspensions for leaving the bench and accruing technical fouls. Andrew Bynum himself got TWO games for a flagrant foul this very season for a somewhat similar but far less egregious flagrant foul on Michael Beasley. I mean, even in this series, Ron Artest got a one game suspension for way less than what Bynum did.

    To expect that he'll get only a one game suspension or, somehow, no games is nuts. Dave V. isn't far off in his reaction.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I mean to say that I agree with Dave V. Sorry, my last sentence just reads weird to me.

    ReplyDelete
  30. It's not acceptable in polite society to bring this up.............but I have no doubt the race of the Dallas players factored heavily into the fouls committed by the Lakers.

    ReplyDelete
  31. @jkak --

    Yeah, right. Ain't nothin' easier than coaching the best player(s) in the game, is there?

    Remind me again: what is the *combined* total of championships won by MJ and Kobe without Big Chief Triangle as their coach?

    ReplyDelete
  32. n what? seriously.... That's one of the most narrow minded and unjustified comments I've seen in a while.

    ReplyDelete
  33. @n - So you have "no doubt." It's great to be a mind reader, isn't it? What isn't acceptable in polite (or decent) society is to make accusations of racism without basis. Are you channeling Murray Chass, by any chance?

    ReplyDelete